"There was a time when I thought that my task was to show children how to solve their problems.
I wrote: I do not ask you to stop thinking about play. Our contract reads more like this: If you will
keep trying to explain yourselves, I will keep showing you how to think about the problems you need to solve.
After a few years, the contract needed to be rewritten: Let me study your play and figure out
how play helps you solve your problems. Play contains your questions, and I must know what questions
you are asking before mine will be useful.
Even this is not accurate enough. Today I would add: Put your play into formal narratives,
and I will help you and your classmates listen to one another. In this way -you will build a literature of
images and themes, of beginnings and endings, of references and allusions. You must invent your own
literature if you are to connect your ideas to the ideas of others."
l
The two projects DECOLAP (1995/96) and DECOPRIM1
(1996/97) introduced Vivian Gussin PALEY to a wider public in Luxembourg concerned with preschool and
primary education. Until 1996 V G. PALEY taught at the kindergarten at the University of Chicago Laboratory
SchooIs. A fascinating series of books documents her
work as teacher and author, and retraces her way as a "reflective practitioner" - as she defines herself.
V G. PALEY received an Erikson Award for Service to Children in l987 and a MacArthur Fellowship in l989.
Her latest book,
The Girl with the Brown Crayon, has been awarded Harvard University Press's annual
prize for an outstanding publication about education and society. This book describes the author's
pedagogical journey in her final year of teaching. Together with her pupils she explores the themes
of identity, race and gender through the landscapes of the characters in Leo Lionni's books.
On 10th March 1997 following an invitation to Luxembourg, V G. PALEY held a conference in Walferdange
with the title STORY AND PLAY: THE ORIGINAL LEARNING TOOLS.
This conference was at the same time the introduction to a short seminar in which the ideas, the working methods
and the results of the DECOLAP project were presented to a wider audience of teachers.
Accompanied by the coordinators of the DECOPRIMl project V G. PALEY visited the kindergarten
class of Martine Geib in Niederanven. She met the participants of the DECOLAP and the DECOPRIM1
projects and the participants of the DECOLAP in-service training courses to discuss story acting
and storytelling, classroom theatre and culture.
| The titles of the courses were |
|
DECOLAP - A L'ÉCOUTE DES ENFANTS (given by Paul DUMONT, Roger FRISCH, Martine GElB, Gérard GRETSCH, Claudine KIRSCH,Jeanne NOUR EL DlN-LETSCH, Christian SCHWARZ) |
|
DIALOGUE AVEC LES ÉLÈVES - WHORF, BAKHTIN ET PALEY (given by Gérard GRETSCH) |
| On the following day PALEY held a workshop called |
| HOW TO BE A TEACHER, A WRITER, AND A RESEARCHER IN YOUR OWN CLASSROOM This title summarizes the complex task she fulfilled in her own professional career and at the same time restates some of the aims of the projects DECOLAP and DECOPRIM1. 50 teachers participated in this workshop. |
| The other workshops held by participants of the DECOLAP and the DECOPRIM1 projects had the following titles: |
|
Storying: histoires vécues, jouées, décrites, dessinées par les enfants
Storying: stories experienced, played, described, drawn by children held by Martine GEIB, Marie-Paul ORIGER-ERESCH |
|
Écrire, est-ce un jeu d'enfant?
Is writing a child' s play. ? held by Gwendy DECKER, Carole STOOS |
|
A l'écoute des enfants
Listening to children held by Maryse PAULY-MEISCH |
|
Les médias à l'école préscolaire
The media in the kindergarten held by Roger FRISCH and Marc WANTZ |
|
Collaboration entre classes: préscolaire-primaire / primaire-primaire
Collaboration between classes: kindergarten-primary school / primary school-primary school held by Brigitte CLAEREBOUT, Nathalie JAEGER and Christian SCHWARZ |
|
Collaboration avec les parents: Le "language record" comme exemple d'une telle collaboration Collaboration with parents: The "language record" as an example of such a collaboration held by Claudine KIRSCH and Jeanne NOUR EL DIN-LETSCH |
In the afternoon session V. G. PALEY introduced the audience to her views and experiences concerning
writing. She focused more particularly on the transcription of tape-recorded dialogues of her pupils
used both as a research technique and as a means for developing dialogue in the classroom.
However, the purpose of taping classroom conversation is not to capture what children say
in the absence of direct adult observation, nor are the recordings disconnected from the author's
writing. V. G. PALEY explains: "the reason for writing about the classroom is because the writing process,
and whether or not you use a tape recorder is not essential, explains what I am thinking. In a sense I do not
know what I am thinking until I make it clear on a page. I do not begin to get the clues of what children might
be thinking until I transcribe their voices."
The next important step in her investigative procedure is to bring the transcribed conversations
back into the classroom. She thus turns her classroom group into a "continual debating society"
to which "let's pretend" is a "scientific method for imagining what might happen".
Vivian PALEY understands her role as a "connector of bits and pieces of conversation that not everyone has heard".
In other words, the teacher's role is "to create community".
|
V.G. PALEY's approach to teaching in a preschool can be applied to
teaching in higher classes or even to how a project group works. |
Investigating the process of learning in the classroom by recording classroom conversations and
transcribing them is only one aspect of PALEY's research method, which has been adopted as a
general procedure by the teachers involved in DECOLAP and DECOPRIM1. All DECOLAP and DECOPRIM1
publications are the result of teacher's investigations concerning themselves and their teaching As V G.
PALEY puts it, "I use writing as a tool with which I explain life to myself or even myself to myself. (...)
Nothing is more important than explaining yourself. No matter what else is taught."
Finally, an important aspect of V. G. PALEY's approach - particularly relevant also
in relation to the aims of the present project - is the way she involves the children's parents
in her work. She has described this in her book
Kwanzaa and Me
"Just as theatre is expressed in so many ways, so is storytelling a multi-dimensional art form.
It must constantly be invented and reinvented. Most importantly, it must represent the classroom community
in which it occurs. In some groups there is a strong tradition of storytelling upon which to draw; for
others television, cartoons, or fairy tales supply character and plot and rhythm. No matter what the
derivation, the inventiveness and spontaneity of the teacher and students will suggest how the storytelling
and story acting proceed and develop. "
2
The power of a project lies in the dynamics it creates on different levels of
learning and teaching. The teacher's involvement in a project, be it an official research
project or a personal teaching project, has an undeniable effect on classroom culture, on
classroom dialogues and on classroom work.
The more aware children are of what the teacher is honestly interested in,
the more it will affect their attitudes towards learning. If the teacher is
interested in what the children do and think, the children will be interested in
what the teacher does and thinks, and this will feed back on teaching. Engaged in
such a dialectic process the teacher and the children will come to speak, act and think differently, nothing
will remain untouched. It is the awareness of what the work is all about, and the interest in what everyone
does and thinks that create a different classroom culture. Everyone's interest contributes to shape and reshape
everybody's identity and connect it to the identity of other's. "They know that the reason why I am taping
their conversation is to continue the dialogue", says V G. PALEY. For everyone involved it seems to be clear
that everyone else is investigating the question of "who it is I'm living with in the classroom ".
V G. PALEY's conceptual framework rests on the assumption that "children are interesting to each other".
The interests children develop naturally can be fostered as they can be curbed. Thus it is not necessary
to involve an entire class simultaneously in one and the same project. In a group, different children can
very well be involved in very different projects. It is up to the teacher to determine how many different
activities he can cope with. The crucial factor is the interest everyone has in what the others do. Without
the interest in another person's work and thought, the will to investigate, "the eagerness to come to
school to see what happens today", there is no hope for a different classroom culture, hence, a
different teaching culture beyond the dogmatized discussion about "childcentricity versus teachercentricity".
Are teachers and their work interesting to other teachers to the same extent?
Inviting parents to come into the classroom "to tell family stories, memories of when they were
young, or stories of grandparents, other family members or family traditions" creates new perspectives
for the teacher's work by extending what socio-cultural context, identity and classroom culture mean.
We are happy to publish - with the author's permission - the